I was using TPB for a decade when I decided to try to join that "Demonoid" I read in many torrents contents.
Was not so easy, Google took me to BTJunkie, KAt...
And this amazing new thing to me, a "private" tracker, EuroTorrents (a little brother of AsiaTorrents). It was a kind of magic !

Mine was BitMe.org 2004

my first private torrent tracker was Demonoid (hope they come back)

torrentday

Demonoid , back in the day

Filelist everyday all day baby

Demonoid here too.

I think that the first one was "extremeshare.org", but was closed 1 year later. After, filelist.

my first was torrentleech, entered through open sign up. One of the best trackers out there for any kind of stuffs.

I only have 1 until now, MyAnonamouse