honestly, i'm completely biased.
the p2p scene has come quite away, and it is in my eyes just a copy of the underground scene that started years ago.
people who may have applied and got rejected or banned for whatever reason started their own scene to prove that they are just as good if not better. but p2p required a medium such as torrenting for it to take off. the scene already had the network built for it.

this is just my 2 cents being an ex-scener

I am a scene freak ...I really love scene releases because it's always trusted and the bad releases quickly get trumped

scene releases there is a standard to uphold most groups are trustworthy scene over p2p anyday

well i vote for both..For games i always take scene release and for movies i take p2p and scene release

I think P2p

Scene for fast uploading . P2P for quality.

well said D !!

i use AND like both XD

Ofcourse p2p!!

Definitely p2p wins the race for the quality.

P2P for quality

It depends on the type of content
for movies and tv shows for example I don't really care which release it comes from as long as the quality is what I'm looking for
for appz and games I only go for scene, never downloaded a p2p released video game before,even if it takes longer I'd rather use a scene release because its much safer and more reliable. no disrespect to all the p2p games/appz groups out there, your work is also appreciated but thats just me and thats how it is.