Gameplay is most important, because a sick eye candy game still ends up being unplayable if it sucks after 10 minutes. But it's definitely a plus to have it.

People still play the original Zelda game from 25+ years ago!

I'd prefer a game with good gameplay and meh graphics any day of the week

always always gameplay. Then graphic

Is better a good gameplay, but graphics atract a lot of attention to the game.

Gameplay but you could chuck story in there as well for some game types. Like take the witcher 2, gameplay (fighting bits) where actually a bit poop but it has great graphics and a pretty good story.

crysis 2 and 3 have the best graphic ever
but the really suck in gamplay

This topic is totally misleaded it's not about graphic at all if you want graphic watch sci-fi movies
it's all about story / game-play however having good graphic is a bonus
so what kind of game you are into?
If you are going to massively multiplayer online games then Game play for sure however having a good graphic is a bonus
however offline/multiplayer it's all about the story and the game-play however having a good graphic is a bonus

Gameplay from quality

Super Mario Bros, Capcom vs Street Fighter 2 Alpha, Megaman 8, Metroid Prime, Golden Eye 007, Perfect Dark, Legend of Zelda, and Shenmue all prove that gameplay is king. That is why there are people who still play retro arcade games. That said graphics are always icing on the cake. Gameplay will always be King.

Gameplay