Gameplay for sure
even the graphic was to bad FF VII was EPIC

I'd prefer a game with good gameplay

Gameplay all the way, I still enjoy a text based MUD over some of the graphically amazing MMOs that have no content or good gameplay. Of course if you ask my nephew it is all about the graphics

Gameplay. What do you want graphics if the gameplay is terrible?

Gameplay is more important than the graphics to me, tbh.

gameplay makes the game, hands down.

Gameplay for sure, especially if it has a solid single player campaign along with multiplayer.

While the Game play is very important, I do feel that the overall look and environment is what really puts things into perspective. I cannot get into a game that lacks visual appeal. I must run all my games on Ultra settings if possible at all times or else I do not wish to play.

No game is better than it's game play. Graphics, well as long as they don't annoy me (which both 8bit or AAA 2016 graphics can do) I don't really care. Usually I lower all graphics except shadows to min.

Game Play all the way. The simpler games seem to be the most fun.