Eyecandy is nice, however after some time your eye will get use to anything you trow at it. So yeah gameplay ftw.
Some oldies are still very much enjoyable even though they don't have very good graphics.

Both gameplay and graphic

Always gameplay. Then graphic.

Graphics ofc, My eyes are the one playing #kappa

Gameplay

Gameplay , of course.

Gameplay always first.

i prefer gameplay,but the game will not be perfect without good graphic .

Both are important, if the gameplay is great but the graphics are bad then you will not be able to concentrate on the process of gaming.
However, good graphics with bad game is worse.

The most important to me is Gameplay