Everyone's saying gameplay>graphics, but when a game looks like crap, it doesn't make a good first impression.

always gameplay

Gamplay first.. some of those 2d games have awesome gameplay but not that great graphics

I say 60% Gameplay and 40% Graphics because if the gameplay is shit but the graphics looks nice then whats the point you know

Gameplay all day, but it needs to have okay graphics anyway. Games that focus everything on graphics are great looking for an hour or two, but becomes stale really fast. Games with great gameplay stay fun long.

graphics!

Gameplay

Graphics, if we are talking about anti aliasing, contrast, temporal anti aliasing and other stuff that makes the image clean.

Both. More graphics doe.

A bit of both but gameplay for me because graphics won't do much if there is bad gameplay