Since the earliest days of the film industry, movie studios have had two options: adapt or die. But this latest step from one of the biggest studios in the game could be a leap in the wrong direction.

Sony Pictures has announced that thirteen of its films will be released in the 4DX format next year. 4DX movies are the ones in which your seat shifts underneath you and you’re pummeled with smells, blasts of air, and drops of water based on what is happening on screen. You know what this means: get ready to be neuralized for real during Men in Black International.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, Sony has signed a multi-picture deal with CJ 4DPLEX, the Korean exhibitor that created 4DX technology, which “augments and enhances the experience of a film with 21 sensory effects, including seats that move and vibrate in tandem with the action on the screen, dynamic bursts of light and a range of other integrated elements, such as scents, wind, water, snow and more.”

Here’s the list of Sony movies that will be available in 4DX in 2019:

Escape Room – January 4
Miss Bala – February 1
Greyhound – March 22
The Intruder – April 26
BrightBurn – May 24
Men in Black International – June 14
Grudge – June 21
Spider-Man: Far from Home – July 5
The Angry Birds Movie 2 – August 16
Zombieland 2 – October 11
Charlie’s Angels – November 1
Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle sequel – December 13
Masters of the Universe – December 18

A Sony executive says that all of these movies “lend themselves to the 4DX immersive experience,” but that’s hard to believe. Sure, some of these might be fun to see in that format – I can see it working with a horror movie like Grudge or Escape Room to heighten jump scare moments. But watch the trailer for Miss Bala and please tell me how having things blasted in your face during the movie would enhance that experience.

I don’t want to slam Sony too hard here. They obviously think this is a step toward getting people excited about going to theater again, and with a lifetime of entertainment options available to people on their couches at the touch of a button, I understand that’s an uphill battle. But have you ever been to a 4DX screening? It’s more expensive than a traditional movie ticket, and you’re essentially paying for a jostling, jerky experience equivalent to a carnival ride. I appreciate that Sony is looking to the future, I’m just not convinced 4DX is the way to go. I’ve always found the true full-size IMAX experience to be the most immersive way to watch a movie – maybe invest in a deal with IMAX to allow your filmmakers to film using native IMAX cameras? Just a thought.