Hello Guest, welcome to torrentinvites.org - Your #1 source for Torrent Invites!
CLICK HERE to register for free and gain full access to TI.org!
Torrent Invites! Buy, Trade, Sell Or Find Free Invites, For EVERY Private Tracker! HDBits.org, BTN, PTP, MTV, Empornium, Orpheus, Bibliotik, RED, IPT, TL, PHD etc!
-
Extreme User
MPAA: Weâre No Pirates! You Are Thieves! Or?
The MPAA is outraged and offended by âThe Pirate Bay and their apologistsâ who âseek to justify profiting from digital theftâ by referring to Hollywoodâs founders as pirates. Not true, they claim. Instead, the early inhabitants of Hollywood were independent filmmakers who were censored by a copyright monopoly. They were freedom fighters who saw no other option than to infringe patents for the sake of creativity.
Two weeks ago we published an opinion piece where we pointed out some unfortunately-phrased comments from MPAA boss Chris Dodd.
The former congressman pointed out that the film industry was able to thrive because of intellectual property protections.
âThe ability to give birth to an idea and convert it into economic success, whether it is the content of a film or the technology of the internet, depends on copyright and patent protection,â he said, referring to the history of US film.
We thought that was ironic. Why? Because Hollywood was founded by a group of independent filmmakers who âfledâ from Edisonâs patents, among other things. The full story (see Copyhype) is richer, but itâs a well-known fact that those who now rule Hollywood refused to obey the patents.
To emphasize the irony we described Hollywoodâs founders as âthievesâ and âpirates,â using quotation marks. Aside from these terms, the events described in our article are mostly undisputed. In no way did we say that this history justifies modern-day piracy, we simply pointed out that Doddâs comments were unfortunate.
The MPAA, however, doesnât like to be called pirates. In a recent blog post they refer to the Copyhype post, claiming that what we and others such as Lawrence Lessig wrote is all lies. We are thieves.
âIf you ask the operators of The Pirate Bay and their apologists, theyâll say Hollywood was built by a band of pirates, fleeing stringent East Coast patent protections to a free and open land to create at will. This theory conveniently parallels their own existence, as they seek to justify profiting from digital theft.â
And these thieves are wrong, the MPAA claims.
Hollywoodâs founders were no pirates, but freedom fighters who rebelled against a âcopyrightâ monopoly.
âThe patents at issue were held by the Motion Picture Patents Company, which, through restrictive tie-in agreements and licensing practices, severely impeded independent filmmakers from entering the market.â
Hmmm, that sounds familiar.
These independent filmmakers lost the first patent lawsuit, but eventually the court sided with them.
âThe status quo was challenged, and shortly afterwards, the Supreme Court determined that MPPCâs licensing practices give it âa potential power for evil overâ movie producers which âwould be gravely injurious to th[e] public interest.â This 1917 ruling severely undermined MPPCâs unfair business practices.â
Fair enough, but the MPAAâs version of the truth doesnât change anything about the fact that the founders of Hollywood were challenging existing patents. That they won in the end doesnât mean that patents werenât violated in the years before.
So Doddâs comment that âthe ability to give birth to an idea and convert it into economic success, whether it is the content of a film or the technology of the internet, depends on copyright and patent protection,â is still rather unfortunate.
Especially because Dodd specifically referenced a time where patents were infringed en masse.
Also, the MPAAâs response in their recent blog post is in itself unfortunate. The lobby group says that Hollywoodâs freedom fighters beat Edison because the court agreed that the MPPC had âa potential power for evil overâ movie producers which âwould be gravely injurious to th[e] public interest.â
Interesting, because today the MPAA is also quite powerful. They are the moral judge who decides what films the public is allowed to see. Not just for the major studios they represent, but also films of independent studios who are NOT an MPAA member company.
Through its ratings system they can make or break films, a âpotential power for evilâ for sure. Just ask South Park creator Matt Stoneor watch âThis Film is Not Yet Ratedâ to get an idea of whatâs going on behind the scenes.
Tags for this Thread
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules